SOLAR MARKETTRENDSign in / Sign up
← All blogs

Lead Acid Battery C20 and C5 Ratings Compare the Same Discharge Test

Share on social media

An amp-hour figure needs its discharge duration and test conditions. A larger label at a slower rate is not automatically more useful backup.

A battery quotation that says only “225 Ah” leaves an important question unanswered: at what discharge rate? For lead-acid solar backup, capacity figures measured over different durations should not be compared as though they describe the same test. Read the rate beside the amp-hours before ranking the options.

One battery can have several legitimate capacities

Trojan's public T-105 page lists 185 Ah at the five-hour rate and 225 Ah at the twenty-hour rate for the same 6 V flooded model. These are manufacturer ratings for one product, not competing claims about two different batteries and not guaranteed backup durations for a house. Trojan T-105 specifications

The arithmetic helps explain the labels. Dividing 225 Ah by 20 hours gives a test current of 11.25 A; dividing 185 Ah by five hours gives 37 A. Those calculations interpret the published ratings. They do not authorize an operating limit or prove that a particular inverter load will run for either duration.

Faster discharge changes the comparison

Victron explains that available capacity depends on discharge rate, with lead-acid batteries generally more affected than lithium batteries. The Peukert relationship is one way to account for this behaviour. The manual also distinguishes C5 from 5C: these are not interchangeable ways of writing the same rate. Victron capacity and discharge-rate guide

For purchasing, ask both suppliers for capacity at the same stated duration, temperature and end voltage. If one offers a slow-rate headline and the other supplies a faster-rate figure, ask for comparable data rather than awarding the larger number an automatic win. Where the expected load varies, request a system estimate using the actual load profile and the battery manufacturer's discharge information.

Keep test capacity separate from routine usable capacity

A rating test is not a recommended daily discharge plan. The quotation should separately identify the operating reserve, permitted discharge conditions and expected battery condition. Ask how the inverter's losses and stopping behaviour are treated in the backup estimate. A capacity label alone cannot answer those system questions.

Record the exact battery model, datasheet revision and rating basis in the purchase documents. If a seller replaces a specified model with another “same Ah” unit, repeat the comparison instead of assuming equivalence. This guide does not confirm local stock, pricing or warranty coverage for the example model.

Do not repeatedly discharge a battery to shutdown to test an advertising claim. If capacity is disputed, request an appropriate controlled assessment by qualified personnel. The useful outcome is a like-for-like comparison and a realistic backup design, not an impressive number stripped of its test conditions.

Sources

  1. Trojan T-105 official specifications
  2. Victron capacity and Peukert exponent